https://www.gofromm.com/fromm-family-classic-adult-dog-food

$41.26 for 33 lbs (today’s price) Grain inclusive.

You won’t go wrong (imo), use this as a base, add a tablespoon or more of cooked chopped chicken meat or canned food. A splash of water and always have fresh water available 24/7

I feed a quality kibble as the base, about 2/3rds of the diet, I add a little chopped boiled chicken, plain chicken broth or water, sometimes scrambled egg or a little tuna or something.
My chicken broth recipe /forums/topic/grain-free-2/#post-109751

For science based veterinary medicine go here http://skeptvet.com/Blog/category/nutrition/

Check with your vet if you don’t believe me, most vets speak highly of Fromm.
PS: Feed twice a day, measured amounts (don’t leave food down/free feed). Maybe an occasional snack.

Victor’s is good just like Sanne said. Also Holistic select and health extensions is good, but a little more money.

I would stay away from small companies, new companies and boutique type foods.

Fromm has been around since the 1940’s

Fromm cannot be bought at chewy. What does that tell you?

PS: None of the foods you mentioned appeal to me. Never heard of Victor till I came on this forum and I have no interest in trying it.
Holistic Select sounds boutiqey.
Companies that have been around a long time are more likely to do testing and have a veterinary nutritionist on staff.

Out of everything mentioned here I’d go with Fromm, canidae, or victor. Canidae is excellent. I always recommend it. It’s a great company who grows their own produce and sources most of their meat from family farms.
However I must ask. Why have u been told such a low protein? Does your dog have some health problem that requires it?

Hi Steve seems like you picked good ones. Those are good and also what the others mentioned are good too. I know that doesn’t help b/c too many choices. I been there too. I don’t know what would be best, but they are all good foods.