[Ron A]

Well, it seems to me that your Editors Choice designation needs work. It is more than a little confusing to find five-star dog foods not on the list and those with fewer stars on it. It seems to me that a five-star rating should be required for any food to be selected for Editors Choice.
As for the Blue Wilderness legal battle with Purina, I would point out that Blue Wilderness is vigorously opposing that lawsuit, which is probably filed mainly for competitive reasons in order to squeeze a growing, much smaller competitor. I would also remind everyone that anyone can sue anyone for any reason but winning a lawsuit is a very different matter.

[Ron A]

I just bought an Editor’s Choice membership and at first glance I am confused. My own choice, based largely on reading this web site years ago, is the Blue Wilderness line and though you continue to give it five stars in your regular reviews you do not seem to show it as an “Editor’s Choice.” Like I said, I am confused. Unless there is something at play that doesn’t meet the eye I would think Blue Wilderness belongs on this elite list. And I so nominate it.

[Author]

Posts