Suggested Raw Dog Foods

Share

A raw dog food diet is designed to mimic a dog’s natural ancestral menu. The whole concept of raw feeding is based upon a dog’s instinctive carnivorous bias… her built-in desire to capture (or find) and eat another animal.
Wolf with Raw Food

As unsavory as it may seem, it is completely natural for a wolf to consume the entire animal… meat, bones, organs and all.

And make no mistake about it… a dog is a direct descendant of the wolf.

Dogs are simply not genetically optimized to consume the fifty percent carbohydrate content of today’s commercial kibbles.

Ancestral Diet versus Dry Kibble

No one can argue the dry baked pellets we call dog food aren’t convenient. But the nutrient profile of a dry kibble is nowhere near the nutrient content of a dog’s ancestral diet.

Canine Ancestral Diet versus Dry Dog Food

Notice the higher carbohydrate content of the kibble compared to the dog’s natural ancestral diet. Or how about the dramatically lower protein and fat levels?

The Benefits of a Raw Diet

Feeding a raw dog food diet has many notable benefits

  • Improved digestion
  • Healthier skin and coat
  • Firmer (less smelly) stools
  • Reduced allergy symptoms
  • Better weight management

There have been many reports of improved health when chronically ill pets were switched from a commercial product to a raw dog food.

The Downside
of a Raw Dog Food Diet

A raw dog food diet can’t touch the convenience of a kibble. Just measure and pour. It just doesn’t get any easier.

Yet besides the lack of convenience, there’s another critical issue. Bacterial contamination.

Salmonella and E. coli germs can always be a potential problem with raw meats. Yet the risk of food-borne disease is actually quite low.

That is, low risk for dogs. But not for humans.

That’s because a dog’s digestive system is shorter and more acidic.

Which makes canine infections like these fairly rare.

The real risk of food-borne disease is actually greater for a dog’s human caretakers… not the dog. Yet with proper care and handling, this risk can be dramatically reduced.

How to Use Our List

Below you’ll find a list of the Advisor’s suggested raw dog foods. Of course, this list should not be considered a complete catalog of all the raw dog foods on the market.

For there are others. Many others.

We only provide this small group as a starting point.

As a matter of fact, if you know of a specific dog food you believe we should have included on this list, please feel free to share your recommendations in the Comments section below.

Or if you’re looking for some suggestions yourself, be sure to look through our readers’ Comments to find more good ideas.

Suggested Raw Dog Foods

  • sandy

    What about sunflower lecithin?  Organic cocoa cassava bars have this kind.

    http://products.mercola.com/cocoa-cassava/

  • Toxed2loss

    Who said anyone had to give up chocolate!!!! LOL I order mine (lecithin free) from equal exchange or get Rupunzel’s at the health food store! Be at peace ladies!!!!!! There are more and more lecithin free brands. My daughter even brought me lecithin free chocolate chips. Read the labels. Call the numbers on your favorite brands and ask for lecithin free! GFETE

  • Kabooms mom

    WoW LoL, I feel like a trouble maker! ; )  I agree with Mary Lou, I’m not going without chocolate! I’d be a horrible person!  I guess Stella and Chewy it is. I’d like to do frozen but we live 2+ hrs form stores that carry it and my whole fear with raw is food safety. The dryed raw will make me feel more secure to start. Maybe later I will feel more confident. Thank you all SOOOO much for all the info!!! If it works out and helps I may be back for more advice.

  • Mary Lou

    Thanks, Shawna ~ wondering if I really wanted to know all of that.  ; )  Well, as expensive as ZiwiPeak is, he is finishing what I have!  : )

  • Mary Lou

    Toxed ~ I am not giving up chocolate!! GFETE  : )

  • Toxed2loss

    Hi Shawna, Mary Lou and Kabooms Mom,
    Archer Daniels Midland told me directly that it’s soy lecithin, unless it says differently. People who,are allergic to soy have to void soy lecithin. Sorry, my wonderful Shawna. I’ve been avoiding soy lecithin for more than 15 years. I was a choco-holic, had a standing order card at See’s… But whenever I ate any chocolate with soy lecithin, I’d get reactions. Within 20 min. I actually learned to conch my own chocolate. GFETE you know that argument, ER discussion we have here on DFA about dog foods that claim to be high end but use cheap a** ingredients? Well, if chocolate has lecithin, it ain’t high end!!! Lecithin is a cheap, substitute for cocoa butter. They draw off the cocoa butter and resell it at a considerable mark up, and substitute soy lecithin, a cheap (problematic) fat. It’s been a long time since I did that research on soy lecithin… I don’t have that on either current computer. So you can take my word for it, or not. GFETE

  • Shawna

    Toxed may have info about manufacturing etc that may cause more of a concern then the info I supplied?

  • Shawna

    Awww Mary Lou what a nice compliment :) !!!!  Thank you !!

    Lecithin is an emulsifier which keeps the oil and water in the food/product from separating.  To my knowledge there are three types used (egg, soy and sunflower).  Egg wouldn’t be cost effective and I don’t think has been used much since soy lecithin came to be.  Sunflower is now being used but most on the market is probably still soy.  It would be best to use an organic non GMO soy lecithin if using but there is no way of telling that info without contacting (most likely) the supplier as I’m guessing the company (ziwipeak in this case) wouldn’t know the answer. 

    Since Ziwipeak is made in New Zealand (correct?) there is a better chance that it might be organic and therefore non GMO.

    Lecithin, technically, should not have any soy protein (the allergy causing part of soy) but apparently small amounts of protein can contaminate the lecithin so if allergic to soy — tread lightly until known if allergic or okay.

    In all honesty, lecinthin is in sooooo many products that I kinda overlook the fact that it is included…  Sorry about that Mary Lou :(   Its in the high end, whole food, organic supplements I take and give to my little Audrey.  It’s in the organic, very expensive, chocolate bars I like (Endangered Species – sell for $3.00 to $4.00 for a 3 ounce bar UGHH).

    It probably should be a red flag but if an emulsifier is needed there probably isn’t much choice — you’re likely going to be stuck with soy lecithin…  However, it is far less of a red flag (from my understanding) then soy oil, soy milk and soy protein.

    If interested, this Weston Price document has some really good info imo.. :)   http://www.westonaprice.org/blogs/2010/07/08/questions-about-lecithin-2/

  • sandy

    It’s really easy actually.  Remembering to thaw is the hard part!  I put a days ration in the frig to thaw overnight on a plate and serve the next day in their bowl and then wash the bowl out with soap.  That’s it. And then get tomorrow’s food out to thaw!

  • Kabooms mom

    I have not done any raw at all yet. Lots of very good or high rated foods with some improvement but not a lot. He is about half bald, and the hair he has is a little brittle. He chews himself until he bleeds. Honestly raw is really intimidateing for me, but I am hitting desperation. He’s truely my best pal and baby. I have to get over it and do whatever I can to help him.

  • Kabooms mom

    All very helpful, thank you so much! I will try it!

  • Mary Lou

    Kabooms mom ~ I am not positve about the lecithin?  I have been working with Shawna for months.  She is an expert, IMO, and others.  If it was a red flag issue, she would have let me know.  Perhaps she will see this and jump in. 

    I feed 1/2 a scoop of the ZiwiPeak with a heaping tablespoon of the canned. I add a little warm filtered water. This definitely satisfies our 14lb. guy for one meal.  He is fed twice a day. 

    I usually order everything from Amazon, but as of late, I have found Wag carries ZiwiPeak and Stella and Chewy’s.  The use by dates have been fresher, and free shipping at $49.

  • sandy

    Have you tried a marrow bone yet?  Mine love them! It’s amazes me how they get all the marrow out.  I got a leg bone from the butcher a couple weeks ago and he sliced it for me and it was less than $3 for 6 or 8 pieces.

  • sandy

    The Primal formulas don’t have eggs (at least some don’t).  I didn’t look at them all.

    http://www.primalpetfoods.com/product/list/c/7

  • Kabooms mom

    I hate to be a pest. The ziwipeak I can get on amazon, this is great because we live pretty far from anything! The feeding meter on the site says my dog only would eat 3.8 oz a day, so bag would last 8.5 days or so. It doesn’t seem like much food, will he suffer hunger pains? Also it has lecithin something form soy beans, is that the same as saying soy? He shouldn’t have chicken, corn, wheat, or soy according to the vet. I don’t know if he actually has had a reaction to soy but the rest I am pretty sure about. Egg & corn were ugly rashes. I think peas too but I am not sure. Oy… Thanks again! I am so very greatful. I hate seeing him suffer.

  • Kabooms mom

    Thank you Mary Lou!! I will look for those to try.

  • monkey

    Awesome. Thanks, i think i’m going to order one soon. I usually just throw kibble around the room, they seem to enjoy it haha

  • Mary Lou

    monkey ~ our 14lb. Bichon has the 3″ one.  He really does love it!!  I don’t make it as easy for him as the video showed that Sandy posted.  I make him work for it.  ; )

  • monkey

    Mary Lou, i think it was you that said you had the IQ treat ball. Should i get the 3″ one or 5″ for 2 small shih-tzus? They’re 16 and 9 pounds.

  • Mary Lou

    Kabooms mom ~ our pup has allergies, and it has been an ongoing “adventure” finding foods that agree with him.  Chicken does not suit him either.  He loves Stella and Chewy’s Duck, Duck, Goose (freeze dried) and ZiwiPeak Lamb.  He eats the air-dried as well as the canned ZiwiPeak.  He has had great success with both, but loves the Stella and Chewy’s.  Good luck to you ~ I know all about the allergy route ~ not fun.

  • Kabooms mom

    Can anyone sugest a chicken free raw food. No eggs either. I wanted to try instinct to see if he’d do better but there are chicken eggs in it. I liked it beacuse it said it was pressure pasturized and I hoped that would be safer. Also it can be found at a reasoanble price to try it. He has terrible allergies.

  • sandy

    Haven’t read the doctor’s study yet.  My dogs usually get raw 3 times a week.  Hubby doesn’t give them raw food when I’m at work.  I’ve just recently (2 days now) changed everyone to eating once a day so this should allow me to give them more raw food.  That way I can feed them the raw before going to work!!

  • Shawna

    No I haven’t but I’d like to.  I had an hour long conersation with Jacqueline Hill VP of Answers and REALLY REALLY like her.  She is a member of Weston Price Foundation and therefore really understands food (imo).  She used to be an employee of Nature’s Variety (as was Scott from Nature’s Logic) but left for reasons neither will share with me — imagining its a liable thing. 

    Although Answer’s is not “confirmed” to be complete and balanced in the AAFCO’s eyes they do post the nutrient content of their foods and are within the guidelines I found on Drs Foster and Smith website.

    Answers a bit high in fat but when combining with lower fat foods like Primal this should even out (or only feeding once or twice a week :)

    Answers is conscientious of bacterial contamination just like Primal, S&C and NV but rather then subjecting the food to HPP they do a much more food and digestive friendly thing by adding “kombucha” or fermented tea which adds healthy probiotics and is too acidic for most bad bacteria.  REALLY NICE imo!!  I also LOVE the raw goat milk kefir…

    Did you see the vet who is independantly feeding her (now after adopting another) four dogs Answers and reporting the results (including bloodwork) on her blog?  The link is on the side of the Answer’s main page if you are interested and haven’t yet seen.

    Sorry this was so long just to say I like it and will try when in my area :)

  • sandy

    Wow…guess I’ll keep looking, but they also only get raw couple times a week, not a full time thing.  Have you tried Answers?

  • Shawna

    Hi Kortez TK ~~ I’m one of the ones Sandy mentions that don’t like high pressure pasteurization.  We KNOW it changes the color of the meat.  We know that it damages enzymes as well.  The process of high pressure pasteurizing DOES create heat however depending on how long and at what pressure the food is pressurized depends on the amount of heat created.

    Bravo is more balanced in fat.  However unless you buy the Bravo “Balanced”, the food is not balanced and will create major problems down the road.  NV buffalo and venison are significantly high in fat which displaces protein and other nutrients so I personally would avoid those protein sources.  If you don’t mind HPP, Primal is really a better food imo.  Only the “poultry” products from Primal are subjected to HPP (so the rabbit, beef, venison etc are not HPP).  Darwins is another really good, fat balanced, brand.

    Sandy ~~ watch the fat content of the Nature’s Logic.  I like the ingredients in the food and Scott the owner but the food is HIGH in fat.  Example — the beef has 37.5% protein and a whopping 53.7% fat!!  WOW!!

  • sandy

    Some say HHP or HPP is no longer raw.  Here’s a page with an article for it.

    http://www.answerspetfood.com/products.html

    That being said, my crew eat Natures Variety beef and Primal brands (pheasant, duck, turkey, rabbit, quail) Going to try out a flavor of Natures Logic soon. Look for the protein content to be near or at least twice that of the fat content.

  • http://twitter.com/Korteztk Kortez TK

    What’s a better raw frozen food, Bravo or Nature’s Variety and why?  I’m also interested in how the bison and rabbit varieties are.

    I have a male border collie whose birthday falls on 3/30/03.  He says hello.Thanks.

  • Shawna

    Heather Anne ~~  NICE Christmas for you!!!! :)

    When you are feeding whole carcasses veggies are less important but I still like giving them..  Most of us don’t feed fur and blood (fiber lost when not feeding fur and sodium when not feeding blood as examples). 

    Our world is more toxic then that of the wolf and I think the extra antioxidants and nutrients provided are only a benefit.  Just my opinion though.

    The common ratio is 75/25 to 80/20.  When not feeding whole carcass you would feed 10% organs, 65 to 70 meat, 5% low sugar fruits (berries are great) and remaining low glycemic veggies.

    Chicken is great but it is important to feed red meats too.  Dogs have a requirement for the saturated fats in red meats.  Eggs, tripe, sardines and other fish are also good inclusions.  Tripe and sardines (with bone) are already in the proper calcium to phosphorus ratio and the egg shell can be fed with the egg for the proper ratio. 

    If interested, Dr. Karen Becker and nutritionist Beth Taylor wrote “Dr. Becker’s Real Food for Healthy Dogs and Cats” which is a guaranteed complete and balanced raw diet using chicken, turkey, beef, sardines and eggs in rotation with veggie/fruit suggestions and add supplements that are missing when all organs/glands aren’t fed.  Also balances omega 6 to 3 for each recipe.  You can use your grinder in these recipes.  You can follow them to a tee or use them as a guideline.

    Congrats and have fun!!!! :)

  • Heather Anne

    Santa was good to me this year–I got a chest freezer and a meat grinder for Christmas.  My supplements are in the mail, and I’ll be picking up my first raw chickens (whole carcasses including livers, hearts, lungs, kidneys and gizzards) this week.  I’m going to start out just making food for the cats, and eventually make food for my dog (Alee) too.

    I have read that cats are obligate carnivores, where dogs are carnivorous-inclined omnivores.  When I start feeding Alee raw, what percentage of animal matter to plant matter should I give her?  I have seen 75-25%, 80-20%, and one site that just suggested to give veggies sparingly.

    I have had two pet rabbits for almost 10 years now, so I’m familiar with the different vitamins found in different types of veggies.  Am I correct in assuming that for the veggies I give Alee, if I give her the same kinds and amounts I give my rabbits (mostly dark leafy greens and something sweet in small proportions, like tomato, pepper or carrot) this will be sufficient?

    Thanks!

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Gordon… Thanks for re-posting this feeding plan. I loved it the first time you shared it.

    When comparing this menu to a cup of human-engineered, factory processed food pellets, the beauty of your feeding plan becomes obvious.

    Dietary rotation creates diversity which automatically minimizes the inherent risk of feeding imperfect foods.

    Thanks for sharing it again.

  • Gordon

    The following is part of a comment I post some weeks back under the Bravo Balance thread that I should really copy here where it is even more appropriate, and may help some like TOMO, understand a little more on how and what to feed when considering a more natural and non commercial raw diet. The whole comment can be found at http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/bravo-balance-dog-food/#comment-378991546

    The relevant part of the comment was as follows:-

    And so, the following is some of my own feeding regime provided to my dogs, of which is as an example over say a 2 week period:-

    Monday -

    Breakfast: Rabbit meaty offcuts mixed with a proportion of Dr. Bruce Syme’s Vets All Natural premix (My convenient version or way of providing a percentage of digestible nutrient rich carb matter)

    Dinner: Raw meaty bone (RMB) say a chicken wing each (Not forgetting that my dogs are small class 2: terriers, under 10kg)

    Tuesday -

    Breakfast: Kangaroo meaty offcuts mixed with a proportion of Dr. Bruce Syme’s Vets All Natural premix

    Dinner: RMB, say beef soup bones or marrow bones

    Wednesday -

    Breakfast: Lamb meaty offcuts mixed with proportion offal (organs) say heart.

    Dinner: RMB, say lamb briskets (Meaty lamb ribs)

    Thursday -

    No breakfast – Intentional

    Dinner: RMB – whole chicken frame each

    Friday -

    No breakfast – Intentional

    Dinner: Whole raw fish each, unscaled, with head (most nutritious part) intact. A once a week meal.

    Saturday -

    Breakfast: Whole raw certified organic eggs

    Dinner: Whole wild rabbit carcass

    Sunday -

    No food at all – Intentional fast, as a mimic to Nature for wolves in the wild, who don’t always have something to eat everyday. Intentional fasting is healthy for the dog’s biological and digestive processes.

    Monday -

    Breakfast: All raw liver meal only (A once in every fortnight meal). Liver from any animal suffices, and is one of the most nutrient dense organs available. Especially high in vitamin A. I’ll usually rotate between chicken and lamb liver.

    Dinner: Turkey necks

    Tuesday -

    Breakfast: Pork meaty offcuts mixed with proportion of spleen

    Dinner: Chicken frames

    Wednesday -

    No breakfast – Intentional

    Dinner: Lamb briskets

    Thursday -

    Breakfast: A couple scoops of certified organic yoghurt with juiced kale and or spinach and or sometimes both

    Dinner: Whole raw fish

    Friday -

    No breakfast – Intentional

    Dinner: RMB, say chicken wing and a couple of necks each

    Saturday -

    Breakfast: Whole raw certified organic eggs with proportion of offal, say lung

    Dinner: Chicken frames

    Sunday -

    No food again – Intentional fasting day.

    ETC ETC ETC.

    In between breakfast and dinner, I sometimes provide healthy treats such as air-dried liver, lamb crumbles, pig ears, pig trotters etc.

    Anyway, this is just an example of what I rotate and feed and how. You can do the same and/or feed something like Bravo and/or a rotation of both systems, etc. There is no right and wrong and as long as variety is kept in focus in addition to the mindset of natural and raw real food way of feeding our 4 legged best friends.
    show less

  • Gordon

    TOMO – I hadn’t read your comments before now. May I ask why you want
    raw substitutes as opposed to raw itself? There is no real substitute
    for the best in anything. There are only secondary options. Air-dried
    raw dog foods, like ZiwiPeak come close to actual raw as a substitute.

    Are you worried about the cost of raw, or about bacteria?

  • TOMO

    Awesome! Thanks Sandy!

  • sandy

    TOMO,

    This video lists foods in order of best to worst: http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/choosing-dog-food/karen-becker-best-worst-dog-food/

    I think dehydrated raw and freeze dried raw would be rated higher than kibble since it is less processed.

    But if you’re looking at the numbers, Epigen and Optimal Performance are low in carbs. Wysong Nuture also has some raw pheasant in it, but it is only a small part as is Optimal Performance.

  • TOMO

    Sorry sandy. I just didnt know where else to ask about raw diet substitutes other than the raw diet section.

  • TOMO

    Any ideas on raw diet subs or is there really no good substitute for a raw diet?

  • sandy

    TOMO,

    This is the raw food list. Epigen and Optimal Performance are not raw.

  • TOMO

    Do you think that thw Wysong Optimal Performance and New Wysong Epigen should be added on this list? I am just basing this on your comparison to the natural wolf diet above. These foods mimic that protien, fat, carb breakdown do they not?

    I am looking for the highest quality dog food that is as close to a raw diet sub as possible. I hear bad things about EVO since the purchase by P&G (whether the rumors and bashing are true) and I see mixed opinion on Wysong even though that brand was highly recommended by the breeders of my high content Wolf Hybrid.

    Any help or suggestions?

  • Ronni

    I was under the impression that they only used HPP on the chicken but I went on their site and now realize that it’s also used on the turkey & sardines, the duck, pheasant and quail. Whew. I think my local store even carries the duck and t & s. Options (since we like to rotate)! Thanks so much!

  • monkey

    Ronni, i don’t feed raw so i may not be able to help you much with that. But i went through the Primal canine formulas, only the chicken formula contains flax.