Hi Tia-
You sound very educated for a first time dog owner. Congrats! Rotating kibbles is fine as long as there is no digestive upset. In fact, it is considered healthy to feed a variety of foods to your pup. Such as kibble, canned, dehydrated, and fresh foods.
It is hard to make a recommendation for a picky dog because every dog has different tastes. Have you tried Fresh Pet at all. It is highly rated and isn’t processed as much as kibble. It is also conveniently found at some grocery stores and big chain pet stores.
Check out: http://www.dogaware.com for some advice and books and information on homemade diets and pre-mixes.
Again, congrats on the new puppy. You have a lot of fun times ahead of you!
