I think you as well should assess what the site is for and what in the spirit of that purpose is appropriate.
Janus, you directed the above at me. By site I assume you mean the DogFoodAdvisor. That is a review of dog foods. Thats what it’s for and that is what Mike Sagman does, review dog foods, which is appropriate. He reviews the foods based on their ingredients and guaranteed analysis, which is also appropriate.
Some people don’t review dog foods that way, they seem to think if a food has inferior ingredients but their dogs “look great” on it that it is a good food. It’s not.
