[billhill]

Dear xfileluv

I think the proof of the pudding is how your critter does with the food you’re feeding. Just as people vary in their metabolisms, so do doggies. If there is no reason to avoid what you’re feeding (such as recalls, solid evidence of trend of toxicity or side effects), I’d say you’re ok. The star rating system is rational and helpful but it’s not the same as results of clinical feeding tests.

I had a beautiful (AWESOME!) greyhound and didn’t change Hobbes’s 2 1/2 star food because he was stable and pretty old. Everything is a tradeoff.

I’d say you’re doing very well for your pittie. If continue to monitor how the dog is doing so carefully, you’ll be fine. And it’s not a bad idea to rotate good food choices anyway, since a varied diet helps assure balanced nutrition.

Last thought: I just began feeding my latest doggies on Kirkland salmon meal with sweet potato. Based on ingredients, might be an additional option for your pittie. It’s moderately priced (Costco).

Bill