[pugmomsandy]

Actually, I don’t think I’ve seen beef ribs at Walmart and the other two items might be at the specialty pet stores. I know they can be bought online. Feed stores, farm & tractor stores might also have dried, roasted trachea which lasts at least 15 minutes for my dogs. An example would be Merrick Moo Tubes (I think they’re called that). Pig snout also lasts a long time and gets rubbery. I throw those away before they can swallow it!