[Mike Sagman]

Hi Ron,

Just because a dog food gets a good review (based on its label), a high star rating alone doesn’t necessarily make any brand eligible for Editor’s Choice designation.

True, a high star rating can indeed make a product eligible for consideration. However, there are currently more than 330 dog foods rated 4 or 5 stars on our website. And fewer than 25 have made it onto our elite Editor’s Choice list.

Here’s an article that explains what we’re looking for:

/choosing-dog-food/brand-guidelines/

Hope this helps.