[fey W]

Hi Sue, probably I understand why Patch always whinging only when he see someone or dog walk past or close to him. And the point is that it’s not always best to automatically try to stop it when you don’t feel well. You know Patch won’t stay quiet when he see somebody around him and you don’t want him whinging. To be honest, you’re avoiding that problem. As mentioned above what I said, a dog can be develop some behavior or weakness, which may due to his past life. Just like our human beings, Once a habit is formed, it is difficult and sometimes impossible to shake it off. But the time and emotions you put into would be the best way to correct Patch. You should give him proper traning, and teach him to get used to that situation he met other people or dogs. You should limit your impatience, try your best to help him how to cope with the situation. Remember that, dog also love to socialize and you don’t need to stop him every time. You can give him a sign to tell that’s not right to cry. I believe Patch will feel what you are meaning and slowly correct his wrong behaviors. Finally,hope you like my advice and can help you out.