[Mike Sagman]

Hi Renee,

Thanks for your question. Just because a dog food has a highly rated label doesn’t mean it qualifies to be an Editor’s Choice selection.

Please keep in mind there are currently more than 325 dog foods on this website rated 4 stars or higher. And nearly 100 of those are rated 5 stars.

That’s why we created Editor’s Choice. We (by design) reduced all those products and the 4,000 recipes they represent to just a few top brands to make it easier for you to choose a top dog food.

For a better understanding how we select brands for this special designation, you may wish to visit the Editor’s Choice FAQ page. Hope this helps.