[George Lawson]

You’re not overthinking it — that’s actually a good catch. In this case, the manufacturer should be your first contact since they’re ultimately responsible for the official ingredient list and product formulation.

Chewy just lists what the manufacturer provides, and Dog Food Advisor (DFA) reviews based on that info or what’s on the label at the time. Sometimes updates or reformulations don’t get reflected everywhere right away.

So:

Contact the manufacturer to confirm the current ingredients.

Then you can let Chewy know if their listing is outdated.

DFA doesn’t control those product pages, so no need to contact them unless their review itself is factually wrong.