Is It OK to Give a Dog Milk or Dairy Products?

Share

Dog Enjoying Milk Product
Oh, how Penny used to love ice cream. All I had to do was simply open the freezer door, and in a flash, she’d be there. Looking up at me. Wagging her tail in utter anticipation.

Well, that was before I’d heard that dogs weren’t supposed to have milk or dairy products.  When I asked why, I was simply told that milk was “bad for dogs”.

Until then, I’d never given the subject much thought. After all, Penny’s vet used to suggest hiding her pills inside a slice of cheese.

So, what’s all this fuss about giving dairy products to your dog?  Is it OK. Or not?

Well, that all depends on your dog’s particular body chemistry.

Milk’s Most Disagreeable Feature

Some dogs have no problems digesting dairy products. Yet others experience acute intestinal distress like gas, diarrhea or vomiting.

It all comes down to how your dog handles a specific nutrient found in milk. A nutrient known as lactose.

I know you’ve probably heard of lactose before. But what exactly is it?

Well, lactose is actually a kind of sugar. Not just one single sugar, but two sugar molecules chemically linked together.

In order for a dog to digest milk, the lactose must first be broken apart into its two more basic, easy-to-absorb sugars.

And that’s just it. You see, a dog’s body must be able to produce its own special lactose-splitting enzyme. An enzyme known as lactase.

And that’s one thing very few dogs can reliably do.

Like Humans… Dogs Can Also Suffer
from Lactose Intolerance

Without lactase, a dog simply cannot digest dairy products. And acute intestinal symptoms nearly always arise. This inability to digest milk is infamously known as lactose intolerance.

The same lactose intolerance so many humans suffer from every day.

So, if you’ve ever noticed your dog tends to develop gas or loose stools after having milk, there’s a good chance she may be suffering from lactose intolerance.

Knowing a Food’s Lactose Content
Can Help Your Dog

To be fair, I do have to mention (in rare cases) a dog can be allergic to the protein in milk1.

Other than that, milk shouldn’t be considered toxic for a dog. And no, it doesn’t cause worms either (no kidding, I’ve actually heard that silly rumor myself).

Yet for dogs that are lactose intolerant (as so many actually are), dairy products can present a real problem.

For those pets, there’s still hope.

That’s because a dog’s reaction to lactose can be directly related to the “dose”. The higher the lactose content, the greater the likely response.

Thankfully, not all dairy products contain the same amount of lactose.  Many kinds of cheese and yogurt contain considerably less than milk.

Take a look at this table. Notice that certain fermented milk products contain only minimal amounts of lactose per serving.

Lactose Content of Common Dairy Foods

For example, notice how most cheeses contain very little lactose. About a gram per serving. Sometimes less. Now, compare that quantity to whole milk, which clocks in at a whopping 11 grams.

So, if your dog can’t handle milk or ice cream, why not try one of these low lactose products?

Three Ways to Ease Milk Problems

If your dog seems to be able handle dairy products, then feel free to offer her milk-based foods. Of course, in moderation.

If not, try one of these three simple ideas…

1. Decrease the serving size. Try a spoonful instead of a scoop

2. Choose dairy products with lower lactose content

3. Offer lactose-free milk products

And remember, when in doubt, consult your veterinarian for professional advice.

  1. Wills J, Harvey R, Waltham Centre for Pet Nutrition, “Diagnosis and management of food allergy and intolerance in dogs and cats”, Australian Veterinary Journal, 1994 Oct; 71(10):322-6
  • scoobysnax

    Go with wellness just for puppy…a little pricey, but whats cost to the life of your puppy? Besides, it will save money in long run forbpreventive illnesses due to lack of proper protein and vitamins

  • Pingback: Worried Momma - YorkieTalk.com Forums - Yorkshire Terrier Community

  • bazza

    Humans beg for Alcohol, is it good to keep feeding that?

  • Pingback: low cal frozen kong treat ideas

  • Pattyvaughn

    Even something simple like kennel cough can turn serious, so it’s a good idea to have your vet tell you what signs to look for that an illness is getting worse.

  • Melissaandcrew

    Take him to the vet. Could be something simple like kennel cough as HDM said or somethingore serious like DCM-heart issue-which dobies are predisposed to.

  • Hound Dog Mom

    I would get him to the vet. Has he been in a situation where he’s been around a lot of other dogs recently (dog park, obedience class, kennel, etc.?) or has he recently been vaccinated for kennel cough? It’s possible he could have picked up kennel cough through a vaccine or from another dog. It may be nothing but it would be best to get your vet’s opinion.

  • buddy man

    Hi,I have a 3 year old doberman that has 2 days coughing like if he has something on his throat. What should I do or give him?

  • http://www.facebook.com/Loui24 Stephanie Louise Smith

    My dog also loves dairy products too. She will get moody with us if we forget to give her some milk late at night before we go to bed.
    It is better to keep to a healthy amount for her size and general health (consult with your vet), but she shouldn’t be going hungry. Saying that, some dogs are just naturally really greedy – often seems to be linked with how dominant they were within the puppy litter.
    As an idea from one dog lover to another, my dog’s favourite meal is fresh homemade meaty (with skin but boneless – sorry, that means you need to stick your hands in slimey chicken) chicken stock and cold over-cooked pasta. She is always satisfied after eating that.

  • http://profiles.google.com/nadyasuleman nadya suleman

    jesus christ isnt real anymore you know ?

  • http://profiles.google.com/nadyasuleman nadya suleman

    are you mentally retarded ?

  • mike

    Don’t punch you dad…he is always well wisher..

  • Hound Dog Mom

    Hi DogLover5353 –

    Please read the Dr. Mike’s detailed review on Purina One and research the ingredients: http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/purina-one-smartblend/ . Vets don’t always give the best nutritional advice. If you’re going to feed Purina one I’d suggest at least checking out Purina One Beyond.

  • Cyndi

    OMG! Please do some research and find a better dog food than Purina One! I have been doing research over the past few months, because I was feeding that to my dog and I believe it was part of the reason my dog died and I am 100% sure Purina One is what killed my cat a few years ago. Purina One is CRAP!! Just google Purina One reviews and I guarantee you’ll see more negative than positive ones. Heck, google Beneful too, also made by Purina and you’ll see how many dogs have died from eating that food. And fyi, my vet recommended Purina One too, but honestly after being on this site, vets don’t always know what they are talking about. Good Luck to you and especially your puppy.

  • DogLover5353

    Purina One! it works great and our vet recommended it for our puppy!

  • VIJIT

    my female rottweiler puppy 75 days old..is so week..i am not giving any non-veg food to her…plz tell me that what type of veg food i have to give..

  • kiwi:age 10

    i noticed my dog really likes begging for cheese,milk, and ice cream….vanilla of course. everyone knows chocolate is poison to dogs!anyway, I also noticed she beggs for it more than other food, like chiken and other meats.when i give her milk she loves it. i pour it come back in a minute and its GONE. same with her food. its like she was starving! should i give her more or less food? i give her ice cream on special ocasions ONLY.

  • Pattyvaughn

    How many different beliefs do you have that you believe in Mother Nature or is it Gaia and attempt to quote the Bible one after the other. Just curious.

  • Stoney Medow

    Obviously, driven by motives of profit and greed/palatal lusts, we are breaking the intent of Nature by stealing another creatures milk designed for their babies. And of course, Nature is not mocked, therefore milk of cows turns to poison in the body of man and canine. Regardless of what so called experts say, who have something to gain [if only the blinding of the people to base cruelties] we have full hospitals and mental illness. Consequences of actions, cause and effect.

    Bet you would not like to be denied your first food substance from your mother. Do unto others ……

    The land taken by these backwards practices deny us human foods.

    Udderly ridiculous….

  • Pattyvaughn

    Dairy in the form of kefir , yogurt, and others have probiotics in them. Dairy has high quality protein in it. Cheese is a highly palatable easy to pack healthy treat for times when you need a high value treat. And it is easy to break it into any size you want. Dairy is low in carbohydrates, unlike any biscuit type treat.

  • Steph

    What nutrional benefit does dairy provide if the can tolerate it? Best stick to premium biscuits for nutrional benefit and dental assistance.

  • Pattyvaughn

    You needed to reply to a 3 month old post for that?

  • Condescension

    read the article again, and if you still don’t know give the dog away to someone with a 3-digit IQ.

  • Lachness

    My puppy chewed on a sheet of human medication and ingested some of the tablets. The vet told me to give him some milk to help relieve any nausea. He didn’t get sick.

  • Mike Hamel

    Brendan, Not all dogs have the ability to digest all the things you say they eat. There’s a difference. My Boxer loves all the things you mentioned, plus stones :-( (. This has presented him with some serious digestive issues. Your dogs should be watched and if after you give them anything new, dairy included and, their behavior, demeanor, temperament changes then STOP! It’s up to you, as the owner, to exercise good judgement in the absence of your dogs ability to do so.

  • Pingback: Coughing - Page 2 - Chihuahua Forum : Chihuahua Breed Dog Forums

  • brokenheart

    Sorry to hear about your loss. I lost my 3 1/2 year old Aussie in 2010 to nectorizing pancreatitis. My husband fed him and my other older dog ICE CREAM, vanilla often. I spent over $7000 trying to save his life, but the pancreatic enzymes secreting into his belly cavity won and tore a whole in his venacava causing him to bleed to death. All I could do was watch and tell him I’m sorry and that I love you, momma loves you, as he took his last breath, advice from a broken heart…..don’t feed your dogs ice cream.

  • Pingback: Giving 2% milk to toy poodles - Poodle Forum - Standard Poodle, Toy Poodle, Miniature Poodle Forum ALL Poodle owners too!

  • Greg C.

    Sugars are carbohydrates which are certainly nutrients.

  • Pattyvaughn

    It’s also not a problem for many dogs.  It still falls on the owner to know what they are giving their dog by reading labels.

  • Westie Dad

    I believe this article is right on the mark. Something kept making my little Westie sick and give her excessive diarrhea. Could not figure it out. Finally, I noticed this occurred every time I gave her I gave her Kong Puppy Paste in her Kong. I did not do it very often, so that’s why it did not occur to me. The first and main ingredient in that stuff is “milk”. Quite frankly, there are so many other items you can put in a Kong there is really no reason to use this product. That said, I will not be using this product in the future. People should be made aware of the fact that this products main ingredient is milk, then whey. It surprises me that they would do this knowing that lactose intolerance is a problem with many dogs.

  • Lordbironious

    Don’t Give him anymore

  • Genz1088

    I feed my buddy a milk and after that he suffered from a diarrhea. What should I do?? pls help me

  • Pingback: Anyone dog allergic to milk - Chihuahua Forum : Chihuahua Breed Dog Forums

  • Dav & Rock

    Hey, Hound Dog Mom- Thanks for the advice. I realy like the idea of a variety of foods. On the part about the onions though, does it matter if they are steamed or raw; my daughters’ dog loves raw onions, wierd. We have a question about indoor pottie training. We use the disposable pads, sometimes she uses them and sometimes not. Sometimes she stands next to the pad and goes pottie while she is looking at us, (we just want to strangle her), am I doing something wrong? Bye for now.

  • Dav & Rock

    Hi, Shawna;
    It’s always nice to meet a fellow electricians wife. Well, you are not going to believe it, I was giving her a little of chocolate when I had some. Like brownies. That’s not all of course I made sure we always fed her Ceaser puppy food. We still do! I felt that that was a good choice for her. We had to feed her mother puppy food at the end of her pg., term My daughter has the mother and father and three of the siblines. She was telling me, oh, also my husband David that you are not suppose to feed dogs chocolate. I just thought that my daughter “was a know it all” and “my hubb didn’t was to share his brownies”. I know this sound so childish. But I never had a dog and I wanted to spoil her. Now I just want to make sure she don’t die on me or even suffer because she has a stup-it mommy. I’m glad I was able to meet you and appreciate what you and Hound Dog Mom has told us. Well, got to go, oh, by the way “I stoped giving her chocolate and anything with caffine”. She is doing better. By the way I am not sure how to pull up your pics., wished I could have seen your babbies. I will send you a picture of my baby girl soon. Bye for now and may “My God Jehovah bless you both”.

  • http://www.facebook.com/irene.winstanley.3 Irene Winstanley

    it is the most natural thing ,in the wild, dogs would get poop from the intestines of a prey animal.,my dogs totally love it .horse manure fresh and steaming is their idea of a gourmet treat.

  • Shawna

    Hi Dav & Rock ~~ My hubby is an electrician too.  And we have 8 dogs total including 2 Poms, a Chihuahua and a Chihuahua/Poodle/Boston Terrier mix.

    I agree with Hound Dog Mom!!  Not all “table scraps” are bad for dogs.  And a dogs intestines really aren’t that delicate.  They actually are much tougher then ours.. 

    What types of food were you feeding her and was that in addition to a balanced dog food or instead of?

    Below is a picture of several of my crew..

  • Hound Dog Mom

    Hi daveandrock –

    Don’t feel guilty about what you were feeding your dog, most of us have been there and fed out dogs bad foods until we learned the difference.

    First of all, not all leftovers and people food are bad for dogs. Giving leftovers – healthy leftovers – can actually be a good thing! No dog should just eat packaged dry dog food day in and day out, they need some real food once in awhile. People foods that would be good to feed your dog would be lean meat, eggs (raw or lightly cooked…without a lot of butter of course!), cottage cheese, yogurt, steamed veggies (except onion) and pieces of fruit (except grapes and raisins). Just keep these “leftovers” to 20% or less of your dog’s diet to avoid throwing off the nutritional balance of whatever food you decide to feed.

    As for picking a dog food any of the 4 or 5 star foods on this site would be a good choice. Check them out and pick one that suits your budget and is available for you to buy – or better yet pick a few, rotating foods is a great way to give your dog variety and is healthier than feeding the same food day in and day out. If it’s affordable for you, I’d also recommend picking a high quality canned or raw food to mix with the kibble. Most canned foods and raw foods are higher in protein, fat and moisture than dry food so they’re more species-appropriate.

    Remember variety is key! Don’t feel overwhelmed with all the choices, you don’t have to pick just one food. Get a new food at the end of each bag if you want. :)

  • daveandrock

    Help! I am a new mommy and my husband and I have falling in love with our new baby. She is half Pomeranian and Chiauhauh (?)-spelling on breed. Anyway Oh, my God I just found out that I was killing my baby because of my hard head. But I’m listening now. Please, help us learn to be as good of parents to her as we were to our daughter.

    Question-how do we fix what I started. Feeding her off of my plate. I thought if it wont kill me it wont kill my baby. But now that we know that dogs intestines our so much more delicate than ours we want the best for her. I have this person tell me one thing and other tell me something else. How can I train her to eat what is best for her if there is so many different things to choose from?

    Bad mommy :(

  • Pattyvaughn

    Swiss and cheddar are low lactose cheeses, so any problem they cause will probably be because of extra fat, so pumpkin really works well for that.  Like Betsy, I always keep some on hand.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1140685339 Betsy Greer

    Plain, canned pumpkin is unique in that it helps both with constipation and loose stool. I give it to my dogs often… just because – it has lots of healthy nutrients. I always have several cans on hand . If you happen to have some already, it wouldn’t hurt just to get him a spoonful and let him lap it up. Otherwise, just give him A spoonful on top of his food. He’ll probably really like it and it’s amazing how much it helps.

  • Spartan1077

    My Lab-Akita just ate my 2 slices of Swiss cheese and 1 slice of Chedder, how do I make sure he feels better if he gets diarrhea?

  • Petaprkr

    What about TB?

  • KellyLight

    I got some Answer’s raw goats milk a few weeks ago after a few of the regulars here recommended it. All of my dogs love it and have done very well when given on its own as a treat or mixed in with their food. It also seems to work as an appetite stimulant for my dog Tank, who is sick and doesn’t always want to eat. 

  • Rhonda

    My dogs all love raw milk and do just fine. I think the problem with milk and most dairy products – - for people and pets – - is when the milk is pasteurized. What you have is adulterated food after pasteurization. Pets should not be fed pasteurized milk. Feed raw milk only, straight from the cow or goat.

  • BennyandJoon

    My guys looove cheese

  • Carrollc

    It’s hard to believe that a dog can eat the most vile of the vile – cat crap- but, can’t handle milk real good. My neighbours dog who is my buddy gets ice cream maybe once a week throughout the summer. I bite off some put it in my hand and she takes it from there ( I get 3 to her 1). Luckily, I guess, the amount she gets hasn’t produced any symptoms. I also found out through her initiative that she loved milk. I inadvertently held my glass down low while I was reading the paper. She pigged that like there was no tomorrow. She got about 3 oz., still no symptoms. She doesn’t get milk very often and it’s always just finishing what may be left in the glass.

    I think dry dog food is good for the owners but so so for the dogs. It may say 30%+- protein but there should be a figure there that states % of usable protein. Rules state that for all animals, their food must have this amount of protein. It doesn’t stipulate that it all must be usable to the animal. Our dog gets raw meat regularly. A Canine isn’t a vegetarian although seeing ingredients on the dog food bags would make you think so.

    I have a friend who has a St Bernard and after her search and study she makes her own dog food. If a person dedicates themselves, like she did, to finding out what a dog really needs, food wise, they’ll certainly look at the prepared dog food available now, in a different light.

  • Mfdoom810

    I’ve been giving my boxer milk for the last few years….we usually give it to her when she has a litter of puppies, for some reason it’s all she prefers while nursing. Other than that she gets a bowl of milk on an average of once a month and she doesn’t show any signs of lactose intolerance.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002255322466 Peter Morgan John Davies

    My dog Koji loves drinking milk, I mean he loves it, everytime I make a cup of tea and he sees the milk he starts wagging his tail and licking his lips, I’d heard that most dogs were lactose intolerant and my dog has never showed any symptoms of this, but this has taken away some worry, since I’ve been told countless times that milk was bad and could hurt dogs. I give him a glass of milk in his bowl every 3 days or so, usually before he goes to bed, he seems to be calmer and cuddlier after his glass of milk :)

  • Sharmila2203

    that takes away a lot of my worry! Benjy, my pet lab looks totally disinterested in milk. I have tried home made cottage cheese . He likes it.

  • C Linds

    How bout lactose free milk? I hope no worries, cause Rollie just had about a quarter cup.

  • Brendan Getchel

    Bummer on your loss. Bloat is a horrible way to die  :-(

    I’m not a vet, but I don’t think anyone could answer your question without an autopsy. However, it is unlikely that milk was the culprit unless your dog had displayed symptoms at some point during the previous two years. You should see some of the things dogs eat(!!) Dogs (every dog) *love* to eat fresh cow “patties” in our pasture. They *love* the raunchiest, maggot-filled decomposing carrion they can find. They “love” to chew on any garbage they come across, and all of this on a full stomach! Unfortunately, they will also imbibe harmful stuff the nanosecond you look away (antifreeze, etc).
    This is *all* dogs, and their digestive system is uniquely suited to deal with these (disgusting) character traits. 

    If you don’t believe your sweet, little precious would ever defile themselves by eating cow poop, bring them over to our farm and watch in horrid amazement as they hunt for the freshest turd on the field, and then gobble it down like it was heavenly manna ;-)

  • Brendan Getchel

    We have dairy cows and drink RAW milk. My wife was “lactose intolerant” until we started drinking our own milk (well… our cows’ milk) raw (“raw” = unpasteurized). In fact quite a number (every single person we know, in fact) that has severe reactions to processed/store-bought milk can drink raw milk without any problems.

    Anyway, we have a large surplus of milk at times when we (my wife) are milking multiple cows. We give most of it away to family and friends, but our dogs get ~1-2 cups of raw milk, each, mixed in with their food at every feeding. We also put a raw egg (we have chickens, too) in each bowl as well. So, along with their dog food, they get raw milk and eggs. Each dog gets roughly one pint of raw milk and two raw eggs per day (one of the dogs steals her own eggs, so who knows how many she gets per day!).

    We have experienced no issues with any of them, and we’re close to them. No bloating, no gas, no lethargy or other adverse reactions or behavior. Our vet says they’re perfectly healthy and to keep “doing what you’re doing.” Their coats are beautiful!

    Granted, this is our experience, but our dogs are radically different breeds and ages and we have yet to experience any negative side effects from their *raw* milk consumption.

    Perhaps it can be attributed to the same negative issue(s) surrounding human consumption of processed homogenized/pasteurized dairy products?

  • Jeannine M. Schoessler

    One day I put the rest of my milk in my Akita’s dry food. After that, it was the only way he ate. I did this for at least 2 yrs. On 6/1 I lost my precious 7yr old to Bloat. Did the milk have something to do with this?! He never had any negative reactions to the milk whatso ever. Jeannine

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com/ Mike Sagman

    Hi Pshiffer,

    Unfortunately, Dr. Harvey’s is a meatless premix dog food. So, due to the variability in the meat-based protein content unique to each custom mix, it’s impossible for me to assign a reliable rating to premix pet food products.

    Thanks for taking the time to make this suggestion.

  • Pshiffer

    Dr. Harvey’s is not on the list. Has it not been evaluated?

  • sandy

    I can actually buy goat milk near me from the farm store (for people) that the dogs drink too but I also get Answers brand goat milk for the dogs sometimes.

  • Blackhole

    Our supermarkets sell “Puppy milk” in cartons on the pet food shelves.

    On closer inspection, it is 100% goat’s milk (which presumably doesn’t have the lactose content of cow’s milk).

    Our dog LOVES this!

  • Hannah

    My new puppy love a bit of milk with no bad reactions ,yet. Plan to check with vet at next visit. Thanks for your article..

  • mmglasco

    Lactose is a sugar, not a nutrient.

  • Kaliberknl

     Ditto…

  • melissa

     Ferrywinkle-

    Since you feel that way, I won’t tell you what my dogs will do for a klonnnndike bar..hehe

    Jk< but they do eat vanilla ice cream in small amounts and LOVE it-without any issues I will add.

  • Ferrywinkle

    Dogs should never be given ice cream. And this on a website called “dogfoodadvisor” 

    Hopefully no one is following this advice and giving their dogs ice cream and other foods that dogs have no business swallowing. 

  • someperson11111

    aw geez, ohhhhhh okayyyyyy……just one or two slaps then?
    no?

    Ey Bubbles, can you just keep pouring out ALL the milk in the fridge down the drain, til your dad hears you on this?  since apparently, some ppl are all against family violence, so i guess punching around is out….
    If your dad is a mellow type, it seems after a gallon or two disappears, he’d reconsider this “dogs need milk” idea?  
    Maybe it’d only be fair to warn him first, “I sure wish you’d stop giving dog milk, and i worry that i will have to pour out all the milk in our house to protect my beloved dog, but, i’d much prefer to just have you hear me on this, ‘dogs ‘don’t need milk and this dog is NOT tolerating milk’.”
    or whatever is good way to put it.

    Or have him log onto to this thread, we’ll help him.

  • daisy1999

    I think that might be illegal.

  • OddFutureWolfGang

    no more milky for doggy

  • OFWGKTA

    punch your dad

  • nay

    Don’t give it her?

  • Bubbles_223_96

    My lab gets milk almost every day from my father and then she pukes green stuff it looks like Mt.Dew and he says oh it’s fine but I’m not stupid it’s bad I cry every time she pukes I just wish I could make her feel better!!! :(

  • daisy1999

    Close, but no cigar.  Lactose is a disaccharide.  But, glucose + galactose.  Sucrose is table sugar made up of glucose and fructose so its actually a disaccharide also.  And, both of these are made up of 2 hexoses.  Sorry :(

  • Taritarimoo

    Lactose is made of two pentoses!(glucose and sucrose, I think) It’s a disaccaride!!! ^_^

  • http://www.dfwpugs.com/ sandy

    Scott,

    It depends on your dog.  If he doesn’t have a bad reaction to it, it may be ok.  I still give some pills in a piece of cheese if I need to.  If it’s a morning pill, I can stick it in their canned food, but since they only eat once a day I’ll use a piece of cheese or meat to give pills at night or other time of day. It’s not a regular thing for them to eat cheese, but none of mine have had any GI problems with it.

  • Scott

    Is a slice of american cheese slices ok.  The kind that you would put on a grilled cheese sandwich

  • dog health guide

    Dogs generally have been noticed to have problem in digesting milk products, it is now easy to select food with low lactose content.

  • http://www.dfwpugs.com/ sandy

    Try some canned pumpkin puree (two or three spoons) with his meals to firm it up.  Or psyllium powder.

  • maxmabi

    SAY NO to Grapes and Raisins! I am sure you have heard this by now, but here is just one more link to explain why NOT to give these to your pets:
    http://vetmedicine.about.com/od/toxicology/f/grape_raisin.htm

     AND here is another link for more NO NO foods:
    http://www.aspca.org/pet-care/poison-control/people-foods.aspx

    Please FEED responsibly. :)

  • Worshipwarrior88

    no wonder my siberian has watery poop today… i gave him milk for 2 days now & i just notice today that its watery huhuhu ohmy what to do now…. 

  • Worshipwarrior88

    Thank you for this blog… Im having problems with my siberian… I fed him milk & now his poop is wet so it becoz of the lactose….

  • Puppylicious

    grape is really bad for dogs. It is “toxic” to them. It can cause kidney disease.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Greg-Mitchell/100000881181279 Greg Mitchell

    Thank you, I give my pups some milk every now and then…they come out fine…they want it…so in light of the facts you’ve given…I’ll continue on my routine.

  • Toxed2loss

    You pup needs the protein. Yogurt is incomplete, as far as probiotics go. You’d be better off to give him a probiotic designed for dogs. The best one is on healthypets.mercola.com

    IMO :-)

  • kayaknal

    So if my dobe’s gas is of the “rotten egg” variety, he isn’t processing all of the protein in his food.  Since TOTW Wetland is 32% protein, do you think trying a formula with a smaller protein content, say, 24-28%, would help?  Or, should I give him a tablespoon or two of yogurt periodically?

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com/ Mike Sagman

    Hi Kayaknal,

    I completely agree with Shawna’s response to your question. So, because of the frequency of this type of issue, I hope you and Shawna don’t mind if I follow her comment with my own.

    Chronic intestinal gas (flatulence) can be a problem for many dogs. And although gas can be a result of underlying disease states, most of the time it can be directly related to an animal’s diet.

    Dogs are a lot like us humans. Each reacts to a specific food in its own unique way.

    Thanks to an earlier contribution from one of our DFA regulars, one of the best peer-reviewed scientific articles on the subject I’ve come across was published in December 2001 in The Compendium by Dr. Phillip Roudebush from the Hill’s Science and Technology Center and is entitled, “Flatulence: Causes and Management Options”.

    In this paper, the author concludes:

    In general, aerophagia and dietary carbohydrate are the primary contributors to the volume of intestinal gas, whereas dietary protein contributes to the odoriferous gases.

    In other words, swallowed air (aerophagia) and dietary carbs appear to cause excessive gas volume. And undigested protein is responsible for the “smelly” (rotten egg) kind of flatulence.

    Hope this helps.

  • Shawna

    Kayaknal ~~ we had a discussion on this very topic a month or two back.  The conclusion was that stinky gas is caused by bad bacteria and protein maldigestion.  Non-stinky gas is caused by bad bacteria and carbohydrate maldigestion. 

    If we came to the right conclusion (using science based articles) then switching foods may not resolve the problem..  What will solve the problem is adding a digestive enzyme to help digest the protein and a probiotic to repopulate the gut with good bacteria.

    Some foods have herbs etc in them that help deoderize but they are just masking the problem versus resolving it.

    Hope that helps :)

  • kayaknal

    I was looking for an article on gas-producing ingredients in dry dog food, but this is the closest fit.  My situation: I have a 3-year-old male doberman that can clear a room fast with one of his gas bombs.  I feed him Taste of the Wild Wetlands formula dry food, and was wondering if there is/are any ingredients that could be contributing to this?  I am willing to switch dry foods as long as the protein and fat content is comparable to TOTW, because my dobie is high-energy and quickly burns off what he eats.

  • Dotb Inc

    Good information

  • Pingback: Disadvantages of Feeding Adult Dogs with Milk Products | Happy Dog Tips

  • Shawna

    Hi Ms. Moore :)

    Have you heard the warnings about grapes causing kidney disease?  (grapes and raisins that is)

    There has been some mention that it is actually fluoride within the grapes that is the cause.  I don’t think however that they know for absolute sure what the cause is (its not the grape/raisin itself but something contaminating it).  So, some grapes may cause kd while others will not.  They do know that it can take ingesting only one contaminated grape however.

    Obviously you have a reliable source for your grapes.  Be cautious if you ever have to purchase a different source :) ..

  • Ms. Moore

    My opinion is to see a Vet right away if this ever happens again. 2/2012

  • Ms.Mmore

    It may be annoying to you, but have you ever considered the fact that some of us are not as literate in writing tecnique as you may be? Even having a degree in English Writing I sometimes make mistakes in spelling, capitalization, colons, comas, parenthesis, etc. To key faster people just don’t hit ‘shift’. so lightin’ up nd don b such a perfectionist…

  • Ms. Moore

    Goggle “recipes for dog treats”. U should come up with something. Here’s mine:
    Dog Biscuits…1 Tblsp. honey, 1tsp. peanut butter, 3/4 cp. flour, 1 egg, 1/4 cp. vegetable oil (I like Olive myself), 1tsp. baking soda, 1/4 cp. rolled oats, 1/2 tsp. vanilla…preheat oven to 350 degrees, mix honey and peanut butter, put for 20 seconds in microwave, add other ingredients, mix well. Spoon mixture 1 tsp. at a time onto greased (or wax paper lined) cookie sheets. Bake 8-10 min. Be carful not to burn them. When they begin to brown they are done. Cool…store in airtight container.

  • Ms. Moore

    I’ve given my dogs (4) dairy products since puppyhood. The idea is not to over do it. When any one of them developes gas (I mean leave the room gas), I give each a tablespoon or two, depending on weight, of plain low-fat yogurt. For a treat I give them a small slice of Cheddar once a week. Other times they get “Milk Bones” after their last meal of the day. All of them eat slices of apple, pears, raw carrots, grapes, and on occasion, lettuce.  I own a collie mix 13 yrs., an American Standard Bulldog 5 yrs., a Boston Terrirer 16 mths., and a Hybrid (half canine, half Wolf), 1 yr. The article above is correct as to what dairy products can do to some canines, also according to my Vet. Just be careful and keep a close eye on your pet the first time you give them a dairy product.

  • Egerstner49

    I want to start making dog & cat treats, cakes and cupcakes, Can I substitute SOY Milk, or, any other lactose free milk in the recipe??  Also, I have a couple recipes that call for 6 to 8 oz of cream cheese, what can be substituted for that to make is safe for both cats & dogs???

  • kiki

    i love dogs <3 <3 <3 <3

  • kiki

    this is good my dog loves it!!!!

  • kiki

    it helps so much i love you for this thanks <3 <3 <3

  • kiki

    THANKS YOU SO MUCH.

  • Enchantedbuddha

    Thank you very much my Kudos loves a slice of cheese every morning he waits by the refig and loves to lick the stick after we have ice cream and of course no chocolate

  • DEJ

    Most helpful, thanks a bunch!

  • Pingback: Brian’s Treatment Day 2 | fulleer's space

  • COCO

    Thank you , kind soul. Your article was most helpful and my dog thanks you from the bottom of his heart. 

  • Pingback: Are Human Foods OK For Dogs To Eat? - The Fun Times Guide to Dogs

  • Kevin

    My friend bought a boston terrior about 2 years ago. The seller gave my friend a recipe to mix in the dogs food. It consisted of
    plain yogurt, cottage cheese, and pumpkin. This is suppose to be good for their coat and skin. My friend lost the recipe of the amounts to mix together. Do you know of any reliable websites for dog recipes?

  • Shawna

    Michelle,

    They are both an alias.. Both are names from the TV show “The Office”. Michael Scott is the character played by Steve Carell..

  • Michelle

    Mike Sagman, I agree. Also, is this dude’s name dwight schrute or Michael Scott? Well, whatever his name is, if he doesn’t have any useful information, he should just stop trolling. I mean seriously, what a stupid, and annoying comment.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Michael Scott… I’m sorry you find my use of the ellipsis “annoying”. For it was certainly never my intention in researching this topic and posting this article to displease you (or anyone). So, I promise to give your criticism some thought.

    However, I find it difficult to understand how anyone could possibly avail themselves of content like this and yet somehow manage to focus on such a trivial issue.

  • http://dundermifflin.com Michael Scott

    I am referring to the author, Mike Sagman.

  • Michelle

    dwight schrute, who are you talking to? Also, it is really annoying when someone doesn’t capitalize their name! :)

  • http://dundermifflin.com dwight schrute

    Can you please not use an ellipsis in place of a comma when you type? That’s not correct grammar and it is really annoying.

  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja Dog Food Ninja

    Carl, the better question might be “why would anyone give a dog soy milk?”. lol

    Really, though, there is no health benefit that a dog would glean from soy milk. And as Mike said above, at least dairy products have very usable animal fat as opposed to plant-based fats which are less productive in a carnivore.

    Might I also paraphrase Lewis Black; there is no such thing as soy milk, because there is no soy teats. It’s soy juice. But they don’t call it that, because when you say “soy juice”, it kind of make you want to throw up a little.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Carl… Although soy is lactose free (a good thing for a dog), it might be OK. However, since it’s a plant-based food, I’m not so sure it would be as healthy for a dog as a regular lactose-free dairy product (like cheese). In any case, you may wish to check back for a response from one of our other readers.

  • Carl Paul

    is it ok to give dogs soy milk? the pure one :) thanks

  • Pingback: Lactose Intolerant

  • Carolyn

    I have found that when my precious Maddie has hard stools I add fresh pumpkin to her food. Do not give them the pumpkin pie mix just plain pumpkin.It has lots of fiber and they love the taste…

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Harky… If diarrhea symptoms appear whenever you feed a dairy product, you should probably consider eliminating milk from your dog’s diet. If however, you only see the symptoms on rare occasions, it’s not nearly as likely these foods are responsible for the problem.

    Unfortunately, since I’m not a veterinarian and due to the biological uniqueness of each pet, it would be inappropriate for me to provide specific health advice. You may wish to check back for a possible response from one of our other readers.

  • harky

    if my dog is around 5yr old and he had a history of diarrhea (at least every yr) do u think i should stop it?

  • Gordon

    Gabby – Yes, goat’s milk is also extremely favourable to human skin applied directly. I use natural plain unscented goat’s milk soap which has proven skin healing properties. I shower with it every day and it helped clear up some dermatitis I had over a period of weeks.

    I would imagine that you may even benefit your dog by applying raw goat’s milk on a daily basis, directly on the areas of your dog’s skin that has allergies, and rub it over liberally, and see how that goes. You never know, it may just help.

  • Shawna

    Gabby,

    My dog, Audrey, was born with kidney disease and a collapsing trachea. She could not suckle enough milk, due to the trachea, from her mom for proper nutrition. From about 3 or 4 weeks of age til about 6 weeks of age the breeder syringe fed her RAW goat milk and egg whites to keep her alive — the combination saved her life. She is now 5 years old and going strong.

    Answers makes raw pet food and also carries raw goat milk.. I’ve heard A LOT of good things about the product and “RAW” goat milk in general. Here’s some info on the Answers website. http://www.answerspetfood.com/additional.html

    Pasteurized goat milk is no better then any other milk imo..

  • Gabby

    Our local organic pet store had recommended goat’s milk as a remedy for dog food allergies. My bulldog had some pretty bad skin allergies and was thinking about trying it. Has anyone heard anything about goat’s milk and the effects it has on dogs?

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    jazz – how are your kefir grains activated with using pasteurized (dead) milk?

  • jazz

    I give my dog kefir milk from homemade kefir grain’s.he now has no problem with dairy although use semi skimmed pasturised milk. ;(

  • Jonathan

    “There are calculations which estimate how long it took to increase the gene for adult lactase persistence (ALP) in northern Europeans from a pre-agricultural incidence rate of 5% to its present rate of approximately 70% [Aoki 1991]. (Note: The enzyme lactase is required to digest the sugar lactose in milk, and normally is not produced in significant quantity in human beings after weaning.) In order for the gene frequency to increase from 0.05 to 0.70 within the 250 generations which have occurred since the advent of dairying, a selective advantage in excess of 5% may have been required [Aoki 1991].

    Therefore, some genetic changes can occur quite rapidly, particularly in polymorphic genes (those with more than one variant of the gene already in existence) with wide variability in their phenotypic expression. (“Phenotypic expression” means the physical characteristic(s) which a gene produces.) Because humans normally maintain lactase activity in their guts until weaning (approximately 4 years of age in modern-day hunter-gatherers), the type of genetic change (neoteny) required for adult lactase maintenance can occur quite rapidly if there is sufficient selective pressure. Maintenance of childlike genetic characteristics (neoteny) is what occurred with the geologically rapid domestication of the dog during the late Pleistocene and Mesolithic [Budiansky 1992].”

    Read more here…

    http://www.beyondveg.com/cordain-l/grains-leg/grains-legumes-1a.shtml#intro

    It’s more about grains in the diet than milk, but that snippet was interesting.

  • Gordon

    Why thank you Shameless. For that link that is. I’ve currently found an all organic yoghurt at a particular supermarket for me and my dogs, so I’ve not gone ahead yet to make kefir.

    That is, if I can believe it is fully organic. The label and contents suggest so, but I’m always a little skeptical.

    I could always buy some of that raw goats milk off that site, and bathe in it. Raw goats milk has an added bonus that it agrees with human skin and helps heel many human skin type allergies, including dermatitis.

  • Shawna

    I have a cyber friend on another forum that is a “toxic injury specialist”. She has written a white paper on pasteurized dairy and hopes to publish it soon. She asked me to read and critique… I was SHOCKED as I thought I knew a lot about pasteurized dairy. Nope – not as much as I thought.

    Example — they can add aspartame (without labeling it) to milk. I don’t want to reveal her sources but did find this — obviously it’s, at the very least, being considered in milk if they are studying the stability — http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8120202

    The material presented in her white paper was so overwhelming, I had to read the paper three times to completely comprehend what she had written (with references—not just her opinion).

    I hope she is able to publish her paper soon!!!

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    Where to find RAW milk products:
    USA – http://realmilk.com/where1.html
    Other Countries – http://realmilk.com/where-other.html#aus

    For Gordon – Nimbin Valley Dairy (Australia, north of Sydney) appears to have a Sydney distributor:
    http://www.nimbinvalley.com.au/index.php?page=milk

    Mark McAfee – Founder, Organic Pastures, writes “It may seem strange to say or claim this, but Mother Nature is right, her blue print is right on point. It is mankind that has added variables that cause much of the concern for pathogens in our current market systems. Our consumers are made ill by pasteurized milk products and the additives and processing methods.” and “As an American we can buy raw eggs, raw meat, raw fresh juices, so why not raw dairy products?”
    http://www.realmilk.com/safety-raw-milk.html

  • Shawna

    Couldn’t agree more Shameless… Couldn’t agree more. Hee hee hee

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    Hey Shawna – GREAT MINDS think alike, and post comments within one minute of each other!

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    John – Pasteurized milk has adulterated lactase enzymes. My dog gets small amounts of RAW cow milk and sometimes raw goat milk. Also raw kefir. Here is some interesting information about milk and ‘lactose-intolerance’:
    “One reason raw milk is so much easier to digest compared to pasteurized milk is due to the presence of lactase, the enzyme that breaks down milk sugar. . . it is the friendly bacteria in raw milk that facilitate the creation of lactase in the intestine where it is needed. That is why lactose-intolerant people can drink raw milk without a problem. Pasteurization kills these friendly bacteria.”
    http://www.realmilk.com/safety-raw-milk.html
    http://www.realmilk.com/rawmilkoverview.html

    For your dog’s constipation, maybe try some canned plain pumpkin instead of Metamucil:
    http://www.care2.com/greenliving/health-benefits-of-pumpkins-for-dogs.html?page=2

    I would avoid artificial color and sweetener that are in most Metamucil ingredients:
    Metamucil Orange Smooth Fiber Supplement Powder Ingredients
    Sucrose, Psyllium Husk, Citric Acid, Natural and Artificial Orange Flavor, Yellow 6
    http://www.metamucil.com/metamucil-orange-smooth.php

    Sugar-Free Metamucil contains Aspartame (controversial chemical sweetener)

    Psyllium
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmedhealth/PMH0000092/

  • Shawna

    Hi all,

    I hope you don’t mind my adding my two cents about dairy — unfortunately, it’s not positive.

    There are two issues with dairy and the digestive tract. The first is lactose intolerance which usually has symptoms appearing in the gut — pain, gas, bloating etc. When milk is pasteurized the heat damages the natural enzymes. Lactase is the enzyme naturally in raw milk that breaks down lactose. The other issue with dairy is an allergy or intolerance to the proteins in dairy (whey or casein — in all cases I’ve read about it was casein).

    Dairy allergies/intolerances don’t always have symptoms that would be associated with the gut. I am intolerant of dairy and my first diagnosed symptom (which at the time was not attributed to the dairy) was iron deficiency anemia in my early 20s. Second symptoms was b12 deficiency anemia in mid 20s. Third symptoms was iodine deficiency hypothyroid in my early 30′s. Dairy can kill the little hairs in the digestive tract (villi) and cause malnutrition without any other symptoms. In my late 30′s I discovered lattes and a specific kind of parmesean and feta cheeses and had a cheese and a latte (no sweetener) every day. Over a years period of time I got sicker and sicker. I saw three doctors including an internal specialist – no diagnosis. I had alternating arthritis like inflammation in both knees, a blister rash off and on on my scalp, swelling of my extremeties, sinusitus, tinitis, rhinitis plus.. I was finally referred to a M.D. that is also a Certified Clinical Nutritionist and she immediately knew what was wrong and put me on an elimination diet.. Sure enough, dairy was the culprit….

    The point I hope you take away from my story —- dairy is one of four foods that can cause digestive damage which can lead to malnutrition without digestive or other recognizable symptoms. If this is true for humans I imagine it is even worse in canines and felines. If you can get “raw” dairy then I say go for it but be very watchful when feeding pasteurized dairy products.

    Dogtor J DVM has some GREAT (imo) info on dairy and other foods that can cause the issues I’ve experienced. http://dogtorj.com/

    Sorry for the length of this… :)

  • John

    Good article. Some science and common sense.

    My dog LOVES milk, and has exhibited none of the symptoms of lactose intolerance.

    I had stopped giving it to her for years – mainly because I stopped drinking it and didn’t keep it around.

    Recently, she’s been in pain while defecating and has problems with anal fissures.

    I’ve started giving her some milk, with metamucil mixed in – to soften her stool.

    I read a vet comment on another site that milk may be used therapeutically as a stool softener, which confirmed my thinking on it.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Anais… I’d be more concerned about the injury to his mouth. His signs and symptoms appear to include pain, salivation and discomfort probably associated with his dental injury. And not likely lactose intolerance. In any case, since I’m not a veterinarian, it would be inappropriate for me to provide specific health advice. Please visit your vet as soon as possible. Dental infections can be serious.

  • Anais

    My dog is 5 years old. He’s a Shih Tzu and is 19 lbs. Last night he lost a touth in a very small fight (no real fight) but it bled a lot so I gave him half a McDonalds ice cream cone. He was fine and ate dinner after that normally.

    Then today around 5pm I gave him another ice cream cone thinking it would reduce the swelling and pain of his lost tooth (that wasn’t really ready to come out) and now 3 and a half hours later when we returned to the park to run, he wouldn’t get out of the car, he’s salavating excessively and he never does that, he’s starting to shake, he’s keeping his head down, and he has a light wimper with every breath. Could it be pancreatitis or something else? Is this just a really bad stomach ache?

    I know for sure he ate nothing else. He didn’t get into anything. He’s been with me all day. There was no injury from the fight. Does this sound like lactose intolerance?
    I will never give ice cream again!
    Please tell me your opinion.
    Thanks

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Jessica… When used in dog food, tapioca is a natural (non-dairy) extract made from the root of the cassava plant. Tapioca pudding is made with milk. I’m not aware of any dog foods made with tapioca pudding. Hope this helps.

  • Jessica

    I was just wondering if there is other words in products that can mean diary Example Tapioca Starch is made with milk …. Didnt know that until 4years later so is there any other words I should look out for? Thank You for your time. :) Jessica

  • Gordon

    Shameless – This thread has slipped out of the right recent comments list but I remembered that maybe you may have responded so I’ve checked, and thanks for the links.

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    Gordon – Here is some information about kefir -
    http://www.raw-milk-facts.com/kefir_T3.html

    and purchasing kefir grains –
    http://www.culturesforhealth.com/milk-kefir-grains.html

    People share their grains (they continually ‘grow’) so if you find a Kefir Friend, they will usually share their grains:
    Real Live Kefir Grains shared by members worldwide
    http://www.torontoadvisors.com/Kefir/kefir-list.php

  • Gordon

    Shameless – I’m thinking of “killing 2 birds with one stone and using goats milk, as its also agrees with human skin in healing certain itches, and minor dermatological skin issues. Great for a soothing bath.

    Anyway, this is not my strong area of knowledge and am happy for any advice or tips, Shameless re kefir.

    Anyway, I’ve got to go for now, so I’ll read your response tomorrow, is there is any. Cheers.

  • Jonathan

    We are the only animal that intentionally drinks another animal’s milk. We are also the only animal that drinks milk after weaning. I am of the impression that, while occasional dairy may be fine, the constant use of milk and milk products is both unnatural and unnecessary for both man and mutt.

  • ShamelessRawFoodie

    Gordon – You are “on the verge of making kefir” according to your comment today on the Brothers thread. (I thought I’d get the topic over to this more applicable page.)

    How will you make your kefir? Kefir grains? Raw milk? Cow milk? Goat milk?

    We have serious kefir’ers in our raw food co-op. My husband and I have learned a lot from the REAL FOOD purists.

    Also, I’ve learned that the ‘lactose intolerant’ problem that many allude to (for dogs and humans) doesn’t typically apply to raw milk products. Pasteurization alters (adulterates) nutrients and therein lies most problems.

  • Pingback: Greek yogurt for puppies ok? - Golden Retrievers : Golden Retriever Dog Forums

  • arlin ayeras

    how to treat a bad fell puppies to make them feeling well??

  • arlin ayeras

    what are the common sickness of a puppy?

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Arlin… One month old puppies have very special needs. There’s nothing on this website to address the nutritional requirements of puppies this young. Please contact a vet or a knowledgeable breeder for help immediately.

  • arlin ayeras

    hi’i have 2 puppies and their both 1month old’i try to drink them a powdered milk everyday’my problem is’after 4 hours drinking their milk’ 1 of them was vomiting a worms and i think it a roundworms.i need you help…

  • andrew ricky

    My dog Shelly had a gallstone removed. vet said it was due to calcium deposit. Shelly loved milk and ice cream. symtems of the gallstone was trouble urinating and latter blood in urine. after the gallstone was removed she was like a puppy again. Shelly is 15 years old. Aloha

  • Pingback: Is It Fine to feed a Dog Cow Milk or Dairy Products? | www.HallRoad.pk

  • Mike

    My dog is now three. He has been fed Milk, Cheese, Yoghurt, Raw Eggs (though these do seem to give him a little wind, really smelly bad wind) and various other dairy products ever since he was old enough to be weaned from his mother. Never had any problems at all, period.

    The only foodstuffs I have found make him a little loose is when we used to feed him the leftovers from curry night!!!! Made him smell pretty bad as well if I am going to be honest.

    Rule of thumb I tend to go by, if it makes him ill, don’t give it him again. Kind of like small children in that respect!!

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Lynne… Milk itself contains the highest amount of lactose which for many dogs can be very difficult to digest. What’s more, due to the biological uniqueness of each pet, it would be impossible for me to assure you one form of milk would be any safer for your dog than another. Wish I could be more help.

  • lynne

    hi!
    my dog is an adult dog and loves milk, he doesnt seem to have any problems with it but i know its not the best for him, could i feed him puppy formula milk, even tho he is an adult? i would quite like to give him milk every other day as he is only fed once a day in the evening and i feel that feeding him 2 meals a day would be too much for him. he is a small jack russell.
    thanks

  • Jonathan

    That’s great Liz! Milk and meat from grass-fed cows is superior in every way to store bought grain fed junk. Do you feed them raw food, too?

  • liz

    Hello …I give my dogs raw milk from grass fed cows. They also eat yogurt and kefir from the same source. Not being pasturized and being from organic grass fed cows none of the dogs have diarrhea or loose stools. Also get a raw egg from organic free range chickens on a daily basis. Thanks, just thought I would share.

  • Melissa

    Rick Abrams-

    We give our dogs the occassional dairy treat as well, w/out issue-cottage cheese, milk leftover from cereal, ice cream et and have never had a problem either. Its all about the individual dog and knowing what he/she can tolerate.

    If your dog has thin bones and requires calcium supplement however, I would ask the vet about a supplement as I don;t think a dog(like a person) could get enough calcium from just drinking limited amounts of milk.

  • http://www.drianbillinghurst.com/ Gordon

    Personally, I don’t see any reason or benefit in feeding dogs any dairy products apart from yoghurt as a topping from time to time, which hasn’t caused any lactose intolerance to my dogs anyway.

    I’ve also heard, that cottage cheese with its low lactose level is an excellent dairy product to feed a dog. I haven’t personally offered this to my dogs.

    I think it’s all about using common sense. If your dog sees you putting some cottage cheese on toast for breakfast and it wags its tail, and its facial expression is one that would suggest heaving, with anticipation in getting some, then why not trial giving it some cottage cheese, with out the toast?

    I doubt it would die, and if it had a negative reaction, then common sense would tell you, not to give it cottage cheese anymore.

  • Bill

    According to DR. BECKER, a “holistic vet” on the web, “canines are lactose intolerant”, period!

  • Rick Abrams

    We take care of several dogs. Three of them love milk and I have watched them carefully. My main concern was loose bowels, but if anything unusual had occurred, we would have noticed it and stopped. Our dogs are not lactose intolerant and one has thin bones and needs extra calcium.

    I do not see how one can find out if his dog is lactose intolerant by stopping milk. If one wants to find out, I suggest one start with just a little and watch the dog for the symptoms of intolerance.

    This is only speculation, but I would tend to think that dogs which have a genetic history of living on farms may not be lactose intolerant.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Jaqueline… Milk can be a problem for many dogs. I’d recommend you stop feeding your dog milk until you know for sure.

  • jaqueline

    hi,
    So after my dog eats his food i give him some milk and it looks like he enjoys drinking it but lately i have noticed that a couple hours later hes vomiting the food from earlier. i dont know if it is because of the milk or if there is something wrong with him but im not sure if milk can do that?

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Louise… Soy milk is lactose free. And fro humans, it can be a healthy choice. But it’s a plant-based source of protein. And from a canine standpoint, it is a food I (personally) know little about. For that reason, it would be misleading for me to comment here on soy milk or to assure you it is good choice for your dog.

    I any case, your dog’s digestive system appears to be sending you a very subtle message. And one I would be inclined not to ignore.

  • louise

    Hi

    I have been giving my border collie soya milk .It has made im ”looser” and he hasnt been for days..Is this harming him in any way, like he might not be able to digest it..He loves licking my soya yogerts pots, and it seems ok, cos i been giving the yogert pots for ages now, and he has not symptoms..He is 14 years old, so perhaps thats got summat to do with him being off his food..He does eat a little if i put ham, plain pasta or bit of rice in his bowl,but he doesnt eat much.. He does drink loads of water and had no problems going for a wee.. Any ideas, thanks

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Toni… I’m sorry your dog doesn’t feel well. And I would imagine your dog will probably be fine within a few hours. However, since I’m not a veterinarian, it would be inappropriate for me to provide specific health advice. If the situation doesn’t improve or if it looks like your dog is getting worse, you may need to visit your vet. Sorry I can’t be more help.

  • Toni S

    Mike,
    I have a 2 yr old Shih Tzu. We recently moved in with my husbands grandfather to help take care of him. He also has a dog that is severly obese. He has always fed animals whatever HE thinks they should eat. I have asked him repeatedly not to give my dog any food. Today he gave her 2 bowls of milk. Now she is walking around acting strange. she keeps acting like she wants to vomit but is not really gagging. I am assuming this means she lactose intolerant. What do i do? Does she need to go to the vet or will it pass on its own? any info would be great.
    Toni

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Rania… Of all the different types of dog food available, kibble is the most unlike “real” food you can get. You may wish to start with a tasty canned food first and then gradually introduce a kibble. Hope this helps.

  • Rania

    Hi Mike,

    I am a first time dog owner and recently rescued a female 2-yr old chihuahua. The previous owners fed her only human food. It’s been just over a week and I’ve tried several different brands of dog food, but she refuses to eat. To top it all off, she has Lyme disease and must take antibiotics to quash it, so her starvation is becoming a serious concern. I’ve tried weaning her off human food but she just refuses to eat. Any suggestions?

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Nick… As long as your dog is not allergic to milk and is able to adequately digest it, I wouldn’t expect any long term effects. But consult with your vet to be sure.

  • Nick

    I started giving my dog vanilla ice cream and he has been fine, german shepherd boarder collie mix. No diarrea, vomiting ect ect. I started giving him 1% milk, a good bit of it to see what would happen and again, his poo is normal, no vomiting no problem peeing or gas issues. Ive given him milk every other day and sometimes every day and he loves it and it dosent effect his bathroom breaks at all. Just wanted to know if my dog is superhuman, because everyone says dogs cant break it down, but I have yet to see any issues, and every time I bring milk out for a glass, he begs for some. I hope these signs show thats its okay for me to give him milk, expert opinion would be great in terms of long term side effects ect ect.. But he handles it quite well in my opinion!

  • Cathy

    More info about Real Milk:
    http://realmilk.com/
    http://www.realmilk.com/suggested.html
    [Link removed by Moderator due to malware]

  • Cathy

    Nikki – I agree with you about raw unpasteurized cow milk being different (better) than processed milk. Beneficial bacteria and enzymes are destroyed by the high-heat processing. I know people who WERE lactose-intolerant when they consumed pasteurized dairy; when they began consuming raw dairy, their lactose-intolerance *magically* disappeared, and they’ve not ever again had lactose problems! It’s amazing how the body knows what to do with Real Food. Dogs are similar in that they will thrive on Real Food.

  • ed

    Goats milk is better tolerated. I would avoid cows milk, as it is one of the top allergens.

  • Nikki

    I use raw unpasturized milk (from a reputable dairy farm) for me, my dogs, and my rescue dogs. They are a variety of mix breeds and we dont have issues. I feel that the processing of milk changes the chemical make up that helps contribute to the cause of intollerence.
    For lactating dogs, we feed high quality puppy food, very often through out the day vs large amounts at once. Raw diet if we have it or soften the dry with water. Plus leave her dry kibble to snack on through the night.

  • Jamile

    I read the comment above with interest, about the yorkie who itches constantly. I had a similar problem with my terrier. Along with all the itching he also had a pungent dog smell. Trial and error lead me to find some info on a blog and I decided to give it a bash. As it turned out he had a yeast infection. I applied some over the counter topical yeast infection cream and it worked like a charm. No more itching! Hope this helps.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Chloe… Not every dog is equally lactose intolerant. So, 2% milk may be OK for your dog whereas it probably wouldn’t be for others. In any case, I’d still avoid excessive amounts.

  • Mike P

    Chole I gave my dog some yougurt mixed in with her kibble twice and she puked both times . I don’t know if that was the reason or not ??

  • Chloe

    Hi. I Have Given My Dog 2% Milk And She Hasn’t Had Any “Effects” Is That Normal?

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Helen… Of course, there’s no way to know for sure, here. But the lactose content of milk powder is certainly high enough to induce a digestive disturbance in a lactose-intolerant dog.

  • helen

    Hi there.

    I made my dog pumpkin treats. pumpkin,cream of wheat, and powdered milk. I found after she had some of these, the next day she was vomiting and had diahria. she seems fine now, she is on the barf diet. Is it
    possible the dry milk powder, is a problem for her.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Kayla… In most cases, fat is as a very normal part of most any meaty meal. But when you provide mostly fat scraps, you are feeding a higher concentration of animal fat… which many believe can be a direct cause to acute pancreatitis.

  • Kayla betcher

    Hi Mike,
    I have a 1yo, lab huskie mix. My concern is not about milk.. I understand it is bad so im no longer giving it to him. However I saw that meat fats were no good.. I eat alot of meat and always give him the scraps. (fat) Are the bad affects long term or pretty rapid? Because I have not seen any problems off the bat in stool or otherwise, I woulnt feel commfy giving him anymore if there is going to be long term affects. Please let me know asap because i cant take those puppie dog eyes if i dont know it will really hurt him.
    Thank you so much Kayla and Debo. (My dog)

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Krystle… Congrats on your Lab’s new litter. Let her eat as much as she wants during lactation. She’ll burn the food up as fast as she eats it. Unfortunately, since I’m not a veterinarian, I cannot provide health advice or specific product recommendations. Please see our FAQ page. Or check back for a possible response from one of our readers.

  • Krystle Ruiz

    Hi Mike, I just discovered your website and I was hoping to get some advice. My 6 year old Labrador just gave birth to 13 puppies! I know she needs all the help she can get to keep up with such a large litter. She seems very hungry and I would like to know what you would suggest? Any specific dog food or household food?

    Also, how soon could I get her spayed?

    Thank You

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi David… The genetic relationship between lactose tolerance and certain canine breeds would make an interesting discussion. However, I’m not aware of any breed-specific lactose tolerance issues. Wish I could be more help.

  • david biologist

    Dear Mike,

    After reading your interesting informations about lactose intolerance in dogs, I am wondering if there are some dog breeds that are lactose tolerant, even if most of them clearly are not. If such a thing exists, the genetics behind it would be of great interest.
    Thanks in advance for any help.

  • Katrina Beesonella

    Hi Mike .. I like your site. My comment re food: after much research and experimentation I feed my 11 month old mixed breed pooch Science Diet kibbles (vet), and Lean Cuts (appears clean and is made in Canada) wet food (available from Costco and online from the company). She is very active and healthy except for a yeast ear infection (likely from antibiotics for an infected paw injury) recently. I sprinkle 1 cap of acidophilus on one of her feeds. Kat

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Martyn… As long as your dog’s signs and symptoms are truly related to yesterday’s milk “feast”, I wouldn’t think this illness is a serious problem. However, since I’m not a veterinarian, you’ve asked a question I don’t feel qualified to answer. I’d suggest a visit to your vet if things don’t improve soon. I wish I could be more help.

  • martyn

    hello, my son gave my alaskan malamute like 1 litre of milk yesterday and he’s become sick he’s usually very healthy but has thrown up once and also has diarrhea, i haven’t fed him today and after sleeping all day seems to have perked up a little but is still lathargic, will he be ok or can milk have serious long term affects? many thanks martyn

  • Jonathan

    I love the look on the dog’s face in the picture. He’s got the “crazy eyes” for that soft-serve… lol :)

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Rosa Lee… Food is only the third leading cause of allergies. Third behind insects (like fleas and mosquitoes) and atopic non-contact allergies (like carpet mites and dust). If you’re still convinced food is the problem, you may want to read an article we’re about to publish (in a few days) about how to choose a quality hypoallergenic dog food. So, stay tuned.

  • Rosa Lee Pagliaro

    My 3-yr old Whippet seems to have allergies and haven’t found a food that eliminates her itching. She really only scratches around her mouth – severely. About 1 yr ago, a specialist diagnosed a fungus/bacteria; treated with antibiotics, prednisone, topical cream. All helped but it still comes back. Of course the Vets always prescribe Hills Z/D. I am still not confortable with quality of that food. What are your thoughts. (I always purchase Super Premium foods for her — still itches). (p.s. itching is not as bad as it was at first).

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Jessica… My personal opinion about milk is presented in this article. If you have any doubts about lactose in dog food, consider using cultured dairy products that are very low in lactose… like cheeses, yogurt, etc. Hope this helps.

  • Jessica

    I have been looking into a lot of home made natural dog treats and meal recipes online, and a lot of them contain some ingredients that I am not sure are safe for dogs. I have been doing lots of research online, but the opinions are very contradictory. I need to know if milk is safe for dogs, lots say go lactose free, some suggest rice milk, which I drink, but I know that has a lot of sugars, some say soy is good others say soy is terrible for them, some mentioned goats milk, I also drink coconut milk which is low sugar, I don’t know if that is a good option and then some of the recipes call for non fat powdered milk, and I am also having the same problem as far as yogurt is concerned, i know non fat and unsweetened is best but do i go with regular, rice or soy? thank you sorry for all the questions I just can’t seem to get a clear answer anywhere

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Laura… Lawn damage from fecal matter is probably something I’d not know much about. However, we’ve always found these similar lawn “stains” associated with urine (and not feces). Hope this helps.

  • Laura

    I am wondering if nutrition has an affect on the lawn! I have a 1 year old golden doodle sweet girl but is driving me crazy with the brown spots on the lawn. I have just seen Iams is not the best food, (even though the vet suggested that) so I would like to see if changing her food has an affect on this problem. She’s had very loose poops with the Iams, so is clearly not digesting it so well.
    What do you suggest? Thank you!

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Melissa… As long as your dog shows no sign of either allergy (to milk) or intolerance (due to milk’s high lactose content), I probably wouldn’t be concerned. However, there may be a less obvious issue to think about here. If this is the milk left after a bowl of ready-to-eat cereal, there’s likely a notable amount of sugar in the leftover liquid. Sugar has a high glycemic index, which may not be good for your dog over her lifetime. See what your vet says about this. Hope this helps.

  • Melissa

    Hi,

    My Teacup Pomeranian absolutly loves the leftover milk from my cereal. She begs and begs for it until i finally give in and give it to her. I’ve been giving it to her for about 2 months now (not everyday, like once every two weeks) and there doesnt seem to be a problem, but i dont want to be giving her anythng harmful or not healthy. Can you tell me what i should do….give her the milk every now and then? Or not at all?
    Thanks

  • Ian

    My dog likes milk. After he drinks it he dries his beard of on the rug. I usually give him what is leftover from my two year olds bottle at the end of the night. Never farts or burps or nothing.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi John Stephen… You’re right. Goat’s milk is lower in lactose content (about 4%) than cow’s milk (9%). But goat’s milk does not appear to be completely lactose free.

    Just the same, if Hercules is doing OK on goat-type dairy products, I wouldn’t worry about discontinuing his treats. Thanks for sharing your tip.

  • johnstepehen

    I have a very picky pekingese with a very sensitive stomach. Hercules instinctively refuses to eat anything other than a raw food diet, raw veggies/fruit (anything that has a crunch…stringbeans and apples esp). He treats them like a bone and runs away to enjoy his reward. He has always had digestive problems, and as a human benefits from yogurt…i thought it might work for him too. We feed him greek plain yogurt (since it’s made of goat milk. Therefore eliminating the lactose factor altogether. His ‘movements’ are more regular, more solid, and the yogurt smeard all over his face is priceless. Thought I’d make that suggestion. There are goat milk dairy products available in stores now. (at least here in nyc) I’m lactose intolerant myself. Fage or Oikos aree great brands that Herc loves.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Oscar… My primary concern with your question isn’t with mixing milk and dog food together but rather the high probability your dog will not be able to tolerate the lactose in the milk.

  • Oscar

    can i mix milk with dog food

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Peter… Thanks for your interesting story and your recommendation. My only concern here is if you only feed salmon (and nothing else) your dog may not be getting all the nutrients (minerals and vitamins) he (or she) needs. You may wish to consider adding a quality canine supplement. Check with your vet for a recommendation.

  • Peter

    Mike,
    my wife and I rescued a Sheltie at about 6 y.o. a few years back. She suffered from chronic itching & sores on her back and belly, ( not unusual for Shelties). At the recommendation of our vet we started feeding her salmon. In about 6 weeks the sores were all gone and the itching has stopped. It can be bought frozen, in 4 oz. portions and on sale for a $1 a pkg. About the same price as high end kibble. Hope this helps.

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Jean… sorry to hear about your pet’s condition. You may be surprised to hear that chronic itching can be caused by contaminants found in the feed grains used to make many dog foods.

    Many are completely unaware of the little-known link between dog food grains and the chronic itching condition known as atopic dermatitis.

    If you think there might be a connection, why not select a nice quality 4 or 5-star (grain-free) dog food and discuss this potential solution with your vet. Hope this helps.

  • jean davis

    My 4 yr old yorkie-poo..rescued at about 6 mos…is miserable from constant itching. Not a flea in sight, and I bathe her with oatmeal shampooo. she is not eating as she should,but loves her icecream treat at bedtime. Could this be anallergy? I have her on 25 mg hydroxyzine, every 8 hours. would appreciate your input…thanks

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Rob… it is my opinion that lactose-free milk is probably just fine for your dogs… so long as they aren’t allergic to the protein in milk (rare). You may want to run question by your vet next time you get a chance.

  • Rob

    Mike,

    both my daughter and I are lactose intolerant so we only use lactose free (2% fat) milk – is it OK to give a little of this milk to our dogs? They like it and so far I have noticed no more than usual gas emissions (we have a terrier) and their stools are the same consistency as usual.

    Thanks

  • mohamed

    Hi Mike,
    first of all thank you for your care.About the pediree of my dogs,i
    have different lines URSUS,DUX VALCUVIA & PAKROS.
    best regards,
    mohamed

  • http://DogFoodAdvisor.com Mike Sagman

    Hi Mohamed,
    It is difficult to say for sure why your dogs are of smaller bone structure and size. The problem may come from your dogs’ pedigree… or it may come from the way they are being fed. In either case, I cannot (within the limitations of the subject of my blog) suggest a homemade diet that could predictably help your dogs. In the future I do intend to address the topic of homemade dog foods in greater depth. Thanks for your comments.
    Mike

  • mohamed abdallah

    hi,
    i am a small (german shepherd) breeder in Egypt.Here we used to import dogs from Germany mainly & all around the world.Me & my wife we noticed that the puppies which come from abroad are much bigger & have exteremly big bones than those we breed here,by time we knew that the cause of this is the kind of food.for us to buy company foods it will be very very costy.So i would like to know from you what kind of food can we give to our dogs to be so large.We can affort meat,milk,vegetables and all fresh foods.
    best regards,
    mohamed.