Elizabeth, great question. I’ve got one of these too. Great suggestions as well.
My neighbor uses Honest Kitchen basic and mixes in cooked chicken. I’m trying to break her in but the mix is a little green for Hannah girl….. She also has allergies so the vet has her on single source protein.
We have two dogs so I’m trying to find something that will work well for both. Ranger’s issue is borderline obesity. He can and does eat anything.
Also trying to keep this side of $100 per month for the cat and dogs.
Let me know what works for yours!