[Ann S]

I would second the Nature’s Logic suggestion. Unlike some of the other recommended brands, it doesn’t have a lot of peas and such, and the small kibble size works for all size dogs.

It would be helpful if there was a category of editor’s choice for allergic dogs. I can’t use most of the recommended foods because they either have lots of turkey, peas, or both. There seems little benefit to my membership as a result, because I still have to do tons of wading through ingredient lists. I had hoped joining would save me some of that time and work!

[Ann S]

Thought I would just add my experience with Earthborn grain free. One of my dogs can’t eat turkey, so I tried Earthborn’s Great Plains and Meadow Feast, only to learn the hard way that he’s also allergic to peas, which the second ingredient. Since I have avoided foods with peas any higher than 4th or 5th, he’s had no problems. So while it’s very affordable, sadly I cannot buy this brand.
Am a little bummed after splurging to join that I can’t use most of the foods on the editor’s choice list due to these two allergies. Budget is also an issue for us feeding two adult dogs and one puppy who will soon be bigger than the grownups. We give raw once or twice a week.

[Author]

Posts