Thank-you to all of you for your thoughtful remarks.
I realize that there are two opinions on the kidney problems vs. high protein: old school – lower protein, vs newer theory – protein content is not of major significance. Since one of our dogs is older and showing signs of kidney problems, I am trying to err on the side of caution and keep the protein moderate (24, 25, 26%).
Grain free is a diet that many dogs thrive on and, I have been told, is especially good for dogs/breeds that tend towards bloat and torsion. However, there is also some new, tentative research that shows possible links to cardiac problems. Ours, for multiple generation over 30+ years, have thrived on grain, so I would rather stay with a grain base. Incidentally, our vet said she liked the oatmeal base of one of the dog foods better than the more traditional brown rice.
Ours are Shelties – medium small. The only thing I have found that seems to make a significant difference is the “small bites”. For whatever reason, they seem to digest the “small bites” better.
I started from the DFA list of 15 best small bites dog food. Fromm did not show up on that list so I sort of forgot about them. Thank you for bringing them to my attention. Whether or not they have a certified Vet on staff, I have heard many good things about them: quality ingredients, careful production, very few if any recalls, no China connection. Good company.
